Consumer JusticeGovernment Advocacy/Public Records

How to STOP Brutal Rapes, Murder and Torture in Florida’s Prisons (Florida Statute 944.23)

Florida Statutes 944.23

There is a profound human rights crisis in Florida’s prisons and this crisis is only going to make life far more dangerous for every citizen of this state when these prisoners are finally set free.  I’ve been writing about this epidemic of crimes being committed in prisons by guards and by prisoners for some time now and quite frankly some of the responses that are provided by those who view these posts are quite disturbing.

People who say, “Too Bad For Those Prisoners….Let Them Suffer” Don’t seem to understand that when these prisoners are released (as 99% of them are eventually), we are releasing a human being that has become far more damaged and dangerous than when they entered the prison system that is being maintained in our name.  The stories coming out of the Miami Herald are nothing short of breathtaking. The magnitude of this human rights scandal cannot be overstated. Hundreds of deaths, thousands of brutal crimes, a vast and growing population of human beings who should not be suffering the way that they are.

And to those that say, “Too Bad, Let Them Suffer”, you must understand that these human beings are legally required to serve their time, but we as a society are morally and legally required to make sure they serve their time in conditions that would not be considered “cruel and unusual” according to the United States Constitution and the body of case law that has developed.

And with that as background, I provide my very modest proposal that will change the entire nature of this unfolding human tragedy:


Like a growing number of Floridians, I am appalled at the barbaric and inhumane treatment that  inmates in Florida prisons are being subjected to.  Anyone not directly aware of the magnitude of problems in Florida prisons is encouraged to read the gruesome Miami Herald account of Ricky Martin’s death while in a Florida prison. Martin spoke out against prison conditions and was thereafter brutally raped and ultimately murdered.  As detailed in the lawsuit, prison guards not only looked the other way while the brutal crimes were being committed, they even participated in the crimes by creating the conditions that allowed the crimes to occur.  Martin’s ordeal is just one of a multitude reported in an ongoing Miami Herald series. It’s a series that every policy maker and all citizens should be carefully studying because these crimes and abuses are carried out and can only continue under the color of state power. A brutal power that is exercised on behalf of every single citizen of this state.

These crimes and abuses must stop and there is one very effective step that must immediately be taken to help stop them.  Florida statutes contain a unique and powerful law that authorizes elected officials to perform unannounced inspections of any state correctional institution:

944.23 Persons authorized to visit state prisons.—The following persons shall be authorized to visit at their pleasure all state correctional institutions: The Governor, all Cabinet members, members of the Legislature, judges of state courts, state attorneys, public defenders, and authorized representatives of the commission. No other person not otherwise authorized by law shall be permitted to enter a state correctional institution except under such regulations as the department may prescribe. Permission shall not be unreasonably withheld from those who give sufficient evidence to the department that they are bona fide reporters or writers.

The utterly inexcusable problem is that very few of these officials who are authorized to make these inspections have ever actually conducted any inspections.  The elected officials who are given this powerful right to inspect prisons must recognize that given this current crisis, their clear statutory right has  now become a solemn obligation.  It is long past time for every single elected official to fulfill their obligation both to prisoners in state custody and to every citizen of this state and begin making regular, unannounced inspections.  Immediate change will occur when prison leadership, staff and prisoners themselves must begin to expect that regular inspections will occur with increasing frequency.  The statute already exists, the intent is clear and there are no costs associated with fulfilling this clear mandate of state law.  There is simply no excuse that these inspections should not begin to occur immediately.

One final challenge is issued to press both nationwide and within this state. The final sentence in statute can only be read to authorize press to also make inspections of our state prisons. Individual reporters and the press of this state are likewise challenged to exercise the rights provided to them under this statute.


One Comment

  • L Shelby says:

    Thank you !

    Please see. Fla Stat. 944 which states in part that:

    944.012 Legislative intent.—The Legislature hereby finds and declares that:
    (1) ……………………………………………..
    Florida correctional institutions have contributed little to the reduction of crime.

    To the contrary, crime rates continue to rise; recidivism rates are notoriously high; and large prisons have for the most part become schools for crime, making successful reintegration into the community unlikely.

Leave a Reply